• Suicide Squad received negative reviews and disappointed Warner Bros. following the critical response to Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice.
  • Warner Bros. wanted to speed up the development of the interconnected DC Universe, which led to accelerated production and re-shoots of The Suicide Squad.
  • Director David Ayer’s original vision for The Suicide Squad was changed in the editing room, leaving the film unsure of what it wanted to be. James Gunn’s upcoming Suicide Squad will be a quasi-sequel with no connective tissue to the original.

While writer/director David EyreX Suicide Squad was a significant box office hit in 2016, it received generally negative reviews from critics and, as such, was a disappointment for Warner Bros. after a strongly negative critical response (and relatively disappointing box office performance) Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice earlier in the same year. Add to that rumors of significant reshoots and controversy over the film’s final cut, and Suicide Squad was far from the DCEU course correction that many had hoped for. So how did this once-promising DC auteur film end up being effectively erased by Warner Bros. just a few years later? It’s a long story.

To explain what happened to David Ayer Suicide Squad we must first return to Man of Steel. Zack Snyder was handpicked for the Superman reboot based on an idea Christopher Nolan And David S. Goyer - an idea that the duo hatched while working on the script for Rise of the dark knight. Warner Bros. knew that Nolan planned to end his Batman trilogy with a Bane-infused third installment, and were hoping Man of Steel start a new franchise. And while the dour take on Superman was successful, Warner Bros. hoped it wouldn’t be a global hit, especially since rival Marvel Studios had just launched. Avengers to worldwide recognition.

The making of David Ayer’s Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad (Captain Boomerang, Killer Croc, Harley Quinn, Deadshot and Rick Flag) is drenched in rain
Image via Warner Bros. Pictures

But Man of Steel was the beginning, and so Warner Bros. brought back Snyder for the sequel - although it will hopefully speed up the interconnected DC Universe. Indeed, there was no Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice that Snyder was able to proceed with plans to create a series of films set in the same universe, a la Marvel. But while Marvel released five separate films before AvengersWarner Bros. wanted to speed up the process and use Man of Steel continuation as a kind of mini-Justice League prequel.

Batman v Superman was announced in 2013, and Snyder set about developing this film and casting new roles for Batman, Wonder Woman, Aquaman, and The Flash to create his own standalone films. And in 2014, Warner Bros. put Suicide Squad at the forefront, hiring training day writer and fury Director David Ayer will write and direct this gritty, anti-hero movie about the team. By that point, Ayer already had an accelerated schedule - he had only six weeks to write the script, while the casting took place at the same time. Offers have been sent to people like Ryan Gosling, Jake GyllenhaalAnd Tom Hardyand although they eventually passed, Ayer was able to assemble an ensemble from the list of the best, led by Will Smith And Margot Robbie - both fresh from the filming of a romantic movie about swindlers Focus.

First look at Suicide Squad

According to most, shooting Suicide Squadactually went pretty smoothly. Ben Affleck filmed a cameo to further tie the film to Batman v SupermanAnd Jared Leto advertised as the new Joker, having just won an Oscar for his work in Dallas Buyers Club. And a few weeks after filming wrapped in 2015, Ayer and the cast made a surprise appearance at San Diego Comic-Con, where they unveiled a cool streak of footage promising a dark, gritty, dramatic twist on the DC comics title.

The funny thing about this hissing video is that it was never intended for the general public. When the footage was shown at the SDCC premises, it was leaked online in a low-quality version. Warner Bros. struggled and had to decide whether to release on YouTube a crappy version of the first footage from this long-awaited DC movie, or upload a high-res version for all to see. They ultimately decided to do the latter, but with some horror - it wasn’t a real teaser trailer meant to draw in the general public, but instead a sizzling reel of shots meant to piss off Comic-Con fans who were already familiar. with material. . Indeed, since then Warner Bros. refuses to show “exclusive” footage to the Comic-Con public and instead releases everything shown in the hall online.

The irony is that if it wasn’t for this Comic-Con video, we might never have known what tone Suicide Squad originally should have been. Reaction to the Comic-Con footage was positive, but when the film’s first teaser trailer was released in January 2016, the tone was completely different. The footage opened with Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody” and heavily emphasized the comedic moments with the actors. It was clear that Warner Bros. now trying to sell Suicide Squad like your version guardians of the galaxywhich was a huge success in 2014.

Batman v Superman vs Suicide Squad

Ben Affleck and Henry Cavill in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Image via Warner Bros. Pictures

And so this trailer, which didn’t necessarily reflect Ayer’s film, came through like gangsters. But the last nail in the coffin Suicide Squad on the way to a mess he would become Batman v Superman. The highly publicized superhero team movie was released in theaters in March 2016, and Warner Bros. were so optimistic about making this DCEU that Snyder was weeks away from filming the first movie. Justice League movie. And then Batman v Superman not only was it critically acclaimed, but the box office performance was not promising either. It ended up grossing nearly $900 million worldwide, which is a very large amount, but Warner Bros. expected a lot more from the first feature film that brought together two of the most popular superheroes on the planet.

WB Executive Director at the time Kevin Tsujihara (who was later kicked out of his post after a sex scandal) was reportedly “really pissed off about the damage done to the brand”, and the studio became very nervous about Ayer’s depressing tone. Suicide Squad. They sent the film back for expensive (and extensive) reshoots to add more humor, and went so far as to hire trailer editors to take over the editing of the film itself. While viewers and fans were still eagerly waiting Suicide Squadthey had no idea that behind the scenes the film was being feverishly remade.

Suicide Squad release

Suicide Squad
Image via Warner Bros.

When Suicide Squad was released in August 2016, it did well at the box office and was generally liked by audiences, although critics were not much kinder to Suicide Squad what they should have been Batman v Superman, highlighting its disorienting direction and distracting soundtrack. It was clear from the first 30 minutes that, at least for this part of the movie, the movie didn’t really know what it wanted to be, and settled on “let’s try three different opening scenes with completely different songs in a row.” “

Ayer eventually admitted that his “heartfelt drama” had been “turned into comedy” in the editing room, and that the theatrical version did not reflect his intended vision for the film. He gave a negative answer to Batman v Superman but also the success of an R-rated comedy Dead Pool as reasons why the WB was adamant about a recut Suicide Squad and the removal of its more dramatic elements.

Suicide Squad Future

Image courtesy of Warner Bros. discovery.

But money is money, and while Warner Bros. fought new battles against Snyder Justice Leaguethe studio was still trying for the next few years to make Suicide Squad continuation happens. Jaume Colle-Serra (shallows) was the studio’s first choice as director, but he chose to make Jungle Cruise instead of. Then Gavin O’Connor (Accountant) signed a contract to stage and co-write, but withdrew when he discovered Predator birds told a story similar to the one he was about to tell in Suicide Squad 2. Even Mel Gibson at some point was invited to direct the sequel.

And in October 2018, it was announced that James Gann will write and direct the next Suicide Squad movie. The filmmaker was given a choice of DC properties to tackle and chose Suicide Squad with one caveat: he wanted carte blanche. So Suicide Squad a film was born that is technically a sequel to Ayer’s but has no connection to that original film except for the same actors reprising their characters.

Thinking about how Suicide Squad happened in the first place, Ayer was clearly in a difficult situation. Not only was he chasing a release date, but he was stuck in the middle of the studio, not knowing how to create his own superhero movie universe, but sure he wanted to do it as quickly as possible. They panicked. From Ayer’s side, he is ready to bet Suicide Squad behind him. While he expressed support for fans who wanted Warner Bros. released his version of the film - the version, according to him, is the mature version, edited Lee Smithbuilt on the editor’s previous work John Gilroy, and containing exactly zero “radio songs” - the studio has made it clear that it is not going to do this. On July 29, Ayer released a crude personal note confirming the theatrical version Suicide Squad not his version, but also explains why he never tells his side of the story. He wished Gunn and W.B. good luck before concluding by saying that he is done talking about Suicide Squad or “Ayer Cut” in public.

This tale of two suicide squads it’s a pretty perfect quintessence of the drastic changes this industry can go through in short periods of time and the hasty decisions that studios can make when their bottom line is at stake. Five years is an eternity.